The problem in PE portfolio hiring
A critical executive departure can disrupt the operating plan, board relationship and next fundraise. Reviewing the person who left is only part of the work. The review also needs the terms that brought them in: the mandate, decision authority, resources, reporting line and any promised compensation review.
If those promises sit in separate email threads, the company and executive may have different accounts of what was agreed. A dated record gives both sides specific terms to revisit and gives the operating partner a basis for asking who owns the follow-up.
Ros starts that work with a Promise Check on one hire. For an ongoing record of agreed terms and responses, use an Appointment File. If the role itself needs clarification before the appointment, Seat Analysis is a founder-led review of the seat.
What a PE operating partner can review
Write down the promises that matter to the operating plan. Who controls the budget? Which decisions belong to the executive? What team and resources were promised? When should either side raise a change to those terms?
Ros keeps the company's and executive's responses with the time each was given, or shows a missing answer. Where their words differ, the record keeps both accounts. A reported gap is what that side reported, rather than an independently established finding.
In an Appointment File, a reported broken term can open a repair case. The record shows its follow-up owner and next check date when set, and keeps missing assignments visible. That gives the people responsible a specific issue to discuss.
Important framing
Ros records what was agreed and what each side reports. People review that record and make every hiring, retention and employment decision. A response or completed repair case does not establish why an executive stayed or left, or guarantee that they will stay.
Start with Promise Check
Promise Check covers one new hire and up to five promises. It asks both sides about the same terms in the first week and gives the buyer their dated answers in a day-10 readout.
The Promise Check works as follows:
- After purchase, name the hire and write one to five promises. Confirm the executive knows check-ins are coming. The executive confirms their own email address before check-ins begin.
- The company and executive receive the same promises on day 1, day 3 and day 7 after the start date. Each side gives its own answers.
- On day 10, the buyer receives a readout of both sides’ dated answers or missing answers. Where the accounts differ, the readout quotes both.
Promise Check ends with the day-10 readout. It does not continue at 30, 60 or 90 days. Those later reviews are meetings the CEO or board runs. The Appointment File is the separate offer for an ongoing shared record.
Keep ongoing terms in an Appointment File
The Appointment File keeps the agreed terms of an executive appointment in a shared record. The company reviews the terms, freezes the signing copy and invites the executive, company and board or PE sponsor to sign.
On each check-in date, Ros asks the company and executive about the terms. Dated responses, disagreements and missing answers stay on the record. A reported broken term can open a manager-owned repair case; the case closes only when both sides explicitly confirm the repair.
The frozen signing copy, dated responses, repair cases and period-end receipt give the people responsible a record to revisit. They remain responsible for reviewing the evidence and following up with the executive.
Review the role with Seat Analysis
Seat Analysis is a founder-led review of an executive role's scope, authority, resources, reporting line and intended results. The buyer agrees the inputs and scope with the founder, then reviews a written mandate, dependencies and diligence questions. It can be purchased on its own or together with an Appointment File.
Frequently asked questions
What does a Promise Check deliver?
A day-10 readout for one new hire and up to five promises. It shows the company’s and executive’s dated answers from days 1, 3 and 7, or missing answers. Where their accounts differ, it quotes both.
Does Promise Check continue after day 10?
No. Promise Check ends with its day-10 readout. It does not run at 30, 60 or 90 days. For an ongoing shared record of agreed terms, dated responses and repair cases, use an Appointment File.
What happens when either side reports a broken term?
In an Appointment File, a reported broken term can open a manager-owned repair case. Company and executive responses stay on the record. Only explicit confirmation from both sides that the term was repaired enables the case to close; disagreement and missing answers remain visible.
What if the executive role is not yet clearly defined?
Seat Analysis is a founder-led review of the role’s scope, authority, resources, reporting line and intended results. The deliverables are a written mandate, dependencies and diligence questions. It is available separately or together with the Appointment File.
Do I need an HRIS or ATS integration to start?
No. Promise Check starts with one hire and the promises you want both sides to answer. The buyer confirms the executive knows check-ins are coming, and the executive confirms their own email address before check-ins begin.