Why executives leave in the first year: look at what was promised

When a senior hire leaves inside a year, the company usually calls it fit. The executive usually tells a different story: the job was not the one they were offered. Both can be true. Only one of them is something the company can do anything about before it happens.

Two accounts of the same departure

The company's account is about the person: wrong style, slow start, did not gel with the team. The executive's account is about the job: the scope shrank, the budget never came, the CEO stopped showing up.

Nobody wrote down what was agreed at the offer, so there is nothing to check either account against. That gap is the part of executive turnover a company can close.

The psychological contract

Researchers have a name for the unwritten half of a job: the psychological contract, meaning what each side believes the other owes it beyond the written agreement. When an executive concludes the company has not kept its side, that is a psychological contract breach. Studies of it link a perceived breach to lower commitment and to people leaving.

A written list of promises turns part of that unwritten contract into something both sides can read and check.

Five promises that go missing

PromiseWhat the executive findsWhat it looks like
ScopeThe role in the interviews was bigger than the role on day one.A business unit, a region or a function was described as theirs and is still run by someone else.
Reporting lineThey were hired to report to the CEO and now report to someone else.A reorganization after the offer, or a layer added "for now".
Decision rightsThey own the outcome and still have to ask.Hiring, pricing or budget decisions keep going back up for approval.
ResourcesThe budget or the team arrives late, smaller, or not at all.Headcount that was approved in the interview is frozen by the first board meeting.
AccessTime with the CEO, the board or the sponsor fades after the first month.The weekly meeting becomes monthly, then gets moved.

None of these needs bad faith. Most are a business changing its mind after the offer and not going back to tell the person it affects.

Why nobody says anything

A new executive does not want their first month to be a complaint. The company hears nothing and takes that as good news. By the time the subject comes up, it comes up as a resignation, and the conversation that could have fixed it is months too late.

What senior management turnover costs

Work it out from your own numbers. The search fee you paid. The months the seat sits empty, then the months the next person takes to get going. The decisions that waited. What the rest of the team concluded from watching it happen. No outside benchmark will be closer than that sum.

What to do in the first ten days

Ask both sides, in writing, while it is still cheap to fix. A Promise Check emails the same one to five promises to the company and to the executive on day 1, day 3 and day 7 after the start date. On day 10 the buyer gets a readout: each side's answers, when they answered, and where their words differ. Ros does not score the answers. See what a Promise Check is.

What to do for the rest of the year

Reread the promises at each review, and tell the executive first when one has to change. The full list is in executive retention strategies. In a sponsor-backed company the same problem has an extra layer: see executive turnover in PE portfolio companies.

Common questions

What is executive turnover?
The rate at which senior leaders leave a company, whether they resign or are asked to go. Senior management turnover means the same thing one level wider. This page is about the departures that happen in the first year after a hire.
Why do new executives leave within a year?
There is rarely one reason. The reasons a company controls most directly are the commitments it made to land the hire: scope, reporting line, decision rights, resources and access. When those drift and nobody says so, the executive starts looking.
What is a psychological contract breach?
The psychological contract is what each side believes the other owes it beyond the written agreement. A breach is when one side concludes the other has not delivered. For a new executive it usually means the job turned out different from the one they were offered.
Is every early departure a broken promise?
No. People leave for family, health, a better offer or because the job was wrong for them. A written record of what was promised does not prove why someone left. It shows what each side said along the way, which is more than most companies have.
How can a company reduce executive turnover?
Write down what was promised before the start date, ask both sides about it in the first week, reread it at every review, and say so first when a promise has to change.

Start with one hire

Name one executive hire and write the promises you want both sides to answer. A Promise Check is $750, one-time: check-ins on day 1, day 3 and day 7 after the start date, and a dated readout on day 10.

See the Promise Check

More on executive retention